Johnson`s Real Ice Cream in Bexley

The best black walnut ice cream, ever.

Come here once or twice a week my family and I have nothing but good things say the employees are great clean environment highly recommend. Update!! Sept17,19.. My favorite ice cream flavor Raspberry Cheesecake . I'm not one to try new flavors but today I did I tried the Pumpkin it was very good . I will be trying their monthly flavors and keep updating so, try the flavors out. Update!! Oct01,19.. Stopped in to try the fall flavor Apple Strudel all I can say it was delicious.You have to try it you won't be disappointed.

Located on Main St in Bexley the Johnson family has made & served ice cream for decades. Great assortment of flavors and beverages. They don't have a drive thru but have limited parking with Handicap parking & access. You will move clockwise to exit. You can buy your ice cream to take home or eat in. They also serve a few lunch items. Sit at a table or in a booth. In the summer you can choose seating on their front patio. Historical pics & news articles can be seen on the wall above some of their booths.

Terrific ice cream. Better than Jeni's, but that's just my opinion.

Love the pinata colada dairy free ice cream

I like the clown cones. Bexley also has a lot of walking clowns also .

Today was our first time and it was great i got the beef bbq sandwich and it was really good and my husband got the Reuben sandwich and he thought it was really good and the blueberry pie milkshake was a cherry on top. Deff. Will be back.

ALMOST CLOSING & WAS STILL JUMPING, GREAT SERVICE GREAT ICECREAM

Good ice cream and food

They have great ice cream

Black walnut here never taste better

Our first time Here being newer to Columbus..Definitely will be Back!! Friendly and fast service!

I passed by this place every day and finally went inside. The ice cream is incredible! I got a mint chocolate chip sundae with a ton of toppings and it was awesome. It's also a really good price!

Customer service is always great. I tried eggnog flavor for the first time. It was delicious!

They have ice cream, too!

Went there 6/23 around 3. Had some angsty teenager give me attitude about how i ordered my ice cream. Asked if I could have mint chocolate chip and he responded "chocolate or vanilla" to which i responded I just wont normal mint chocolate chip is that what that is? And he goes "obviously not if I'm asking you if you want chocolate or vanilla" I go on to say I'd like 1 scoop of normal mint chocolate chip and he asks in a small or large cup? I say whatever cup one scoop fits in, he rolls his eyes scoops the ice cream and tosses it on the counter and turns his back to me...

Extremely poor service. The young school boys working here do not know how to provide proper customer service. While standing at the counter for 10 minutes, I was completely ignored and neglected, without even a greeting while they continuously made eye contact with me for reasons I'm still scratching my head to understand. there's a pattern I've noticed here and the Columbus Ohio area. I would not revisit this location or any Johnson's locations again. The manager here needs to retrain his employees.

A delicious, totally local ice cream store!

Excellent, good service and terrific ice cream: loved the salted Caramel with pretzels!!

Best ice cream flavors in town and great service. Love the seasonal specials and the Lemon ice cream.

Nice treat

Been going here since I was a little girl over 35 years ago and its never stopped being delicious!!!!!

Don’t get me wrong, the ice cream here is fantastic. I came in at about 9:30 tonight (an hour and a half before close) and ordered two hand packed quarts and a hand packed pint. I’ve worked at an ice cream store before, so I know how annoying it is to hand pack ice cream. I get that you don’t want to make it. However...when I’m spending $26 on ice cream, I at least expect a thank you. I smiled and said thank you to each associate that helped me, two of which said nothing, and the third rudely said “yup.” You can tell the kids here don’t want to be there, and don’t want the customers to be there either. They definitely need to learn better customer service skills if they want this place to have a good atmosphere like it should. I didn’t feel welcomed. Still coming back for the ice cream though.

Best milkshake ever

They have the best ice cream

Johnson’s is a Columbus original that has been around since 1950. They have great tasting ice-cream (including seasonal flavors) that you can get by the scoop. There are various “novelty” ice-cream items, too. If you’d like something savory before your sweets, they have a fine selection on their lunch menu.

Oh boy the 🍦 here was amazing family loved it- sherbet three thumbs up, will definitely visit AGAIN.

Just ok

Great ice cream an great !

Great ice cream

We generally get pints to go and love the friendly service and local neighborhood feel. Their ice cream is FABULOUS! I love Mocha Chip, my brother loves Butterscoth Toffee, husband loves Moose Tracks and/or Mighty Mint Chip.

I had peach ice cream in a waffle cone and it was delicious.They kept everyone moving with the Pandemic we are in.

GOOD ICE cream, the very Best all flavors

Visited Sunday evening and was warmly greeted by the teens working behind the counter. They gave us samples of new flavors and couldn't have been more friendly and courteous. Was surprised to see the comments about poor customer service as they were really personable and humorous. Ice cream, as always, was delicious!

The ice cream is sooooooo good and tasty. I absolutely love it, This was my second time and I ate every bit of it. The Coconut Almond Ice Cream is the BEST 😍

Would rather have greaters ice cream. But super friendly staff

Wonderful customer service. Very clean and peaceful atmosphere.

I love this place. I have to drive 30 minutes to get my favorite flavors but it is worth the drive. I do wish the website would offer more flavors.

Great place to grab some ice cream.

Great ice cream priced fairly! Excellent service!

Melted in my mouth thts all I can say

Reliable. Great as always. Smelled a little strange inside. Probably disinfectant.

Solid ice cream and shakes. They do have deli options also but I personally haven't tried anything on that menu.

Service was excellent as well as the ice cream! A must when you want GREAT ice cream!

Their ice cream is phenomenal!! They make the ice cream there at the shop and if you ever have a flavor that you would like to make up, just let them know and they will make it. They use all natural ingredients and their prices are very reasonable. This is our favorite ice cream shop, you should give it a try because you won't be disappointed!!!!

Had some late night ice cream!!

Their ice cream is the best! Love it. I got an old fashioned banana split there. I got to choose my ice cream and toppings. No vanilla! I think this place is awesome

Amazing ICE CREAM

Johnson's Cappachino Yogurt is the best as are the Nutty Buddy's! However, I'm most often in there for their great tuna salad!!!